This was not the article I had planned for this week. But last Thursday, 5 November, the Nasdaq 100 fell 6.36%, its worst day since March 2020[1]. Goldman Sachs estimated that tech-focused long/short hedge funds lost more than 4% that day, which left them roughly flat for the year[2].
I have lived through days like this in the past with my clients and watched how some of them wrote to their investors about it afterwards. I have seen clients hide on the back of bad performance, and also watched them being economical with the truth about their drawdowns. Sadly, I have enough lived material on how not to handle investor communication to write about for a month. With AI, I’ve also seen clients who wrote to their investors following a drawdown but the prose was useless and devoid of personality. Last year I received such an investor letter from a manager, and all I heard was a bot speaking. No lived experience coming through and no acknowledgement of the facts and the situation.
On Friday 6 November I posted this on LinkedIn:
Hedge fund down after yesterday?
Your investors want answers you don’t have yet.
What do you send them this week?
A LinkedIn post has to fit on a phone screen. This is the long version.
Before investors have to ask
Right now your head is in the positions and the markets. Investor communications might be the last thing on your mind, but now is the time to write down everything you’re thinking as you work through your positioning and your risk management. Dictating takes less time than writing. The least intensive thing you can do is record the internal meetings where you and the team discuss the portfolio and the decisions you’re taking. Check with compliance first. If they won’t let you run the recordings through an LLM, record anyway: going through the transcripts by hand still gives you the skeleton for any investor communication you need. Don’t be fooled into thinking that investor communications can wait for later, because later might be too late.
When managers are down, reporting takes longer. Have you noticed how some of the hardest hit stop sending numbers to the performance databases altogether? To me that is a massive alarm. Everyone knows the trick. If you didn’t report, it’s because you had a drawdown.
So be proactive and tell your investors before they have to ask. If investors are the actual asset owners, they may be nervous about the market. But if they are managing other people’s money, they themselves are having to communicate with their clients about what is happening in their portfolios and they may need additional help from you.
An allocator said this to me this summer: “I don’t want a client to tell me, hey, what happened to this manager? And I haven’t heard anything from the manager. ... If my client heard about it, there’s clearly been enough time for me to hear about it.”
Another one told me in July that a drawdown is only ever a question of when, and “when it does happen, you need to get in front of it. ... flying out to see them, whatever it takes.”
You might be a bit lost about what investors will want to ask you. Broadly, they’ll want to know what happened to the risk management. It’s helpful to go back to the risk DD meetings you had with each investor before they wrote you a cheque and refresh your notes. Expect to be asked: Why weren’t positions cut or reduced? Run me through the process. What did you learn?
Before you answer, be honest with yourself about which kind of bad run this is. Compare it to your historic drawdowns, your previous peak to trough and how long it took you to recover, and your volatility both historically and in the last year.
Sometimes there’s no way on earth your strategy could perform in a market like this. You’ve told investors in every meeting that this is the weather you don’t do well in, so it’s tough, but nobody should be surprised. However, if they aren’t surprised with the directionality of the performance, could they be surprised with the size of the impact on your portfolio? Investors want to hear what you’re doing to limit the losses.
The harder questions will come if your process was built to perform in exactly this weather. If that’s the story you sold, and you “wet the bed”, they’ll want to know why. That’s a much tougher conversation. They will be trying to understand if there have been changes in the investment process, and style drift is one of them.
And then there’s 2008, or COVID, when nobody performs and everyone is grasping for air. Then the question is what you’re doing to make sure I don’t lose everything I have.
What if you don’t have any answers yet?
If you’re in the middle of it and you won’t have new risk rules yet, tell them how you’re thinking about it and who you’re reviewing it with, your board included.
When you do change something, be concrete. Which changes will show results immediately, and when do you expect the others to? Then show them what the drawdown would have looked like with the change already in place, and quantify the difference. You can never do this perfectly, because you can’t roll back the clock, but you can give them an idea. Maybe the result is still not great. What is the difference?
Measure the loss against your own volatility. How many standard deviations was this? Then give your outlook, and say how you’re preparing the portfolio for more days like this.
How it sounds
Investors often learn more about a manager’s character during a drawdown than during the good times. And they will be watching how you communicate and how you handle the business and carry the team.
This is hard. If markets are killing you, your mind is likely not in the best place. You’re not happy, and you shouldn’t pretend to be. Your own money is in there, and you’ve suffered along with your investors. But my point is investors shouldn’t come away thinking you’ve lost your confidence or your mental capacity. It’s a fine balance, and it sounds something like this: “This isn’t what I wanted. But here’s what I’ve done, and this is why I’m confident it’s going to work.”
There’s research on this from the mutual fund side. Hillert, Niessen-Ruenzi and Ruenzi studied the shareholder letters of 5,489 US equity mutual funds[3]. Letters with a less negative tone brought in more money, but when the tone didn’t match the fund’s actual performance, flows fell. So write your honest thoughts and your process first, and only then, if compliance allows it, get an LLM to organise and structure your own words.
Who gets what, and when
Your investors hold a lot of managers. They’re as nervous as you and as busy as you. As one allocator put it to me: “We’re in the midst of the storm. We got investment committees and CIOs and clients and advisors all yelling at us.”
Inboxes will be flooded for days, so put a TL;DR at the top. Someone who reads three lines and scrolls on should still get your message.
Send the same letter to everyone, at the same time. Then block your calendar and offer one-to-ones. Not all of them will want a call. Some will take you up on it.
Run the letter past compliance before it goes out, and agree with them what you can say on the calls. If you show investors what the drawdown would have looked like with your changes in place, that is hypothetical performance, and regulators look hard at how it’s presented. Anything you tell one investor on a call that isn’t in the letter goes to everyone, so nobody acts on information the others didn’t have.
If an investor is with you through a managed account, they saw the drawdown before you wrote a word, as they see the positions. Their question will be different from that of a fund investor, who is worried about the transparency they will only get towards month end. SMA investors are much more likely to discuss how you are staying inside the risk guidelines, and how close you are to a risk trigger.
What if you called the turn and were short AI? You are up and happy and the market is a mess. But it is still early November so you may not want to count your chickens yet. So what can you do?
First, you can tell investors how you are doing (and tick their box that at least that is one manager they don’t need to worry about). Explain when you turned the portfolio, how, and why. Keep the focus on process, because that’s what tells them whether you can do it again or whether last Thursday was a one-off.
But please be tactful. There are a lot of people being hit right now. And investors might want to focus on getting time with managers that they know have been hit so they can make a proper picture of their overall portfolio, especially when they’re fund investors and lack the transparency of an SMA.
If I’m down, should I stop marketing?
Managers often ask me what a drawdown does to fundraising.
If people only talk to you when performance is fantastic, you go wild when it’s up and quiet when it’s down. The problem with this is that an allocation process takes anywhere from 6 to 24 months and you are likely to see some bad performance somewhere along the way. Allocators take so long to invest that someone buying on the back of a peak may very well get in when it isn’t a peak anymore. So your sales process should keep going. As I once told a client, asset raising is like brushing your teeth, you do it every day.
Importantly, the asset raising process has a core component which is establishing a good trusting working relationship between a manager and an investor.
Every investor knows you will have bad months. I say this very often, and I know it is a cliché: “There was a manager once who had really, really good performance. His name was Bernie Madoff…”
Cláudia
P.S. If you need help with any of this, you know where to find me.
Three ways to work with me
A fund manager who wants to work with me on the asset-raising side? Apply here.
Allocating to emerging managers? Get in touch.
Want an hour on your own situation, no ongoing commitment? Book a consulting call.
This publication is provided for educational and informational purposes only. The views and opinions expressed are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of any third party. Nothing contained in this publication constitutes investment, legal, tax or other professional advice, nor should it be relied upon as such. Nothing in this publication constitutes an offer, invitation, recommendation or solicitation to buy or sell any security, fund or other financial instrument, or to engage in any investment activity.



Hi Claudia - this was very helpful. Thank you. The audio version is extremely good so keep going with it please!
For a rough week, a compact investor update could separate three things: what changed, what the process is doing now, and when the next update will come. A promised date reduces the urge to fill uncertainty with vague reassurance.